
courtesy of Paramount Vantage
Nicole Kidman (left) and Jennifer Jason Leigh (right) play sisters Margot and Pauline in Noah Baumbach’s new film “Margot at the Wedding.”
|
With actors such as Nicole Kidman, Jack Black and Jennifer Jason
Leigh, "Margot at the Wedding" should have been a surefire comic
masterpiece.
It isn't.
Writer and director Noah 'Baumbach's follow-up to his Academy
Award-nominated "The Squid and the Whale" is underdeveloped, drawn
out and not as funny as you'd think a film with Jack Black would
be.
The film begins with New England writer Margot (Kidman) and her
son Claude (Zane Pais) riding a shaky train along the Eastern
seaboard to visit her sister Pauline (Leigh) and Pauline's daughter
Ingrid (Flora Cross) at their family home. Margot is visiting to
attend Pauline's wedding to less-than-ambitious fiance Malcolm
(Black).
Malcolm is a strange character who has no job and wears a
mustache because it's "meant to be funny." He's an artist who never
really grew up but somehow finds himself about to be married and
become a father.
Pauline refers to Margot as her closest friend, even though the
two haven't seen each other in years and don't get along. Margot is
partially to blame for this, as she made the mistake of including
her sister's mishaps in past writings, something Pauline has found
impossible to forgive.
The estranged sisters agree to bury the hatchet for the weekend,
but that becomes difficult when it's obvious that Margot hates
Malcolm.
"He's like guys we rejected when we were 16," Margot says to her
sister.
Of course, Margot's rampant drug use and constant drinking don't
help the situation either.
The bitter rivalry and emotional exchanges between the sisters
are the most enjoyable parts of the movie. Their feelings toward
each other often switch from love to hatred in mere minutes.
In one scene, Margot collapses into Pauline's arms in a fit of
laughter, like only sisters would, after reminiscing about
Pauline's teenage boyfriend. Only a couple scenes later, they fight
over who has slept with more men. Kidman and Leigh show sibling
rivalry at its most real and vulnerable moments.
Margot's own life is full of other problems, as well.
She is on the verge of dumping her husband (John Turturro), whom
she finds despicable for no apparent reason, is sleeping with the
neighbor down the road and is terribly protective of her son.
Margot is so controlling of Claude that she won't let him wear
deodorant because she's afraid he'll get cancer from the
chemicals.
The family is unbelievably dysfunctional. The combination of
divorce, infidelity, drug use and sexual traumas create a giant
train wreck. The characters end up wallowing in their own self-pity
for a majority of the film.
Kidman and Leigh inject life into their characters and make them
as interesting as possible, but Baumbach's writing doesn't take
them anywhere. Viewers learn all of Margot's and Pauline's
strengths and faults, but nothing happens to them. There isn't a
clear plot or moral climax to which they can react.
Black's portrayal of Malcolm also has its faults. He stays true
to character until the end of the film when he weeps over possibly
losing Pauline. Black's comedic personality shows through in a
scene that is supposed to be emotional and serious. His blubbering
is unbelievable and completely out of place.
Malcolm has the potential to be the most interesting character
in the movie but, instead, becomes the most annoying.
Stylistically, the jittery camerawork makes the film seem like a
documentary. In one scene, Claude and Ingrid are confronted in a
field by a neighbor boy and the camera darts and shakes around,
which adds to the intensity of the shot.
Although the camerawork may be spot-on, the film as a whole is
not.
Despite a couple of compelling performances and innovative
camerawork, the film lacks something very important: a clear story
line.
Plot: C-
Acting: B-
Cinematography: A-
Overall: C+
|